The Great Silksong Delusion
Let’s address the elephant in the room: Silksong isn't real. It’s a collective fever dream we all shared in 2019, and the sooner you accept that, the sooner you can stop refreshing Team Cherry’s Twitter like a starved pigeon. While you’ve been busy painting your face like a clown, some brave soul actually played 20+ other Metroidvanias this year. Apparently, the genre is currently in its 'experimental' phase, which is developer-speak for 'we don't have a budget, so here’s a weird gimmick instead of a map.'
The Details: Innovation or Irritation?
The industry is currently unspooling a fresh batch of platformers that claim to 'redefine' the genre. We’re seeing games that ditch the traditional map for 'memory-based exploration' (also known as getting lost because the dev was lazy) and titles that swap combat for physics-puzzles that feel like doing homework on a trampoline. These six 'creative' standouts are trying to break the mold, but as we know, when you break a mold, you usually just end up with a mess on the floor. From time-looping mechanics that make you replay the same boring corridor ten times to 'passive' combat systems where you basically just walk at enemies until they die of boredom, the variety is... let’s call it ambitious.
Rogue’s Take: Stop Trying to Be Smart
Here’s the thing about 'experimental' games: they’re usually just broken mechanics disguised as art. I’ve seen these 20-plus titles, and while everyone is praising their 'visionary approach,' I’m over here wondering why my character moves like they’re wading through lukewarm custard. If a Metroidvania requires a 40-minute YouTube video to explain its 'unique' upgrade system, it’s not innovative—it’s poorly designed. Developers are so terrified of being called a Hollow Knight clone that they’re adding mechanics that actually make the game less fun to play. We don't need a Metroidvania where the map is a procedurally generated haiku; we just need tight controls and a double jump that doesn't feel like a suggestion.
Conclusion: Keep Your Wallet Closed
Look, it’s great that people are trying new things. Truly. But 'new' doesn't mean 'good,' and 'experimental' definitely shouldn't mean '$29.99 for an Early Access build.' If you’re desperate for that Silksong itch, these six titles might distract you for an hour before the jank becomes unbearable. My advice? Wait for the Steam Summer Sale when these 'innovative masterpieces' are 80% off and actually have a patch notes list longer than the credits. Until then, stay cynical, and for the love of God, don't pre-order anything just because the trailer has a nice art style. It’s a trap.
Quick Breakdown
| Feature Type | The Marketing Pitch | The Rogue Reality |
|---|---|---|
| Memory-Based Maps | 'Immersive exploration' | You will get lost and cry. |
| Physics-Combat | 'Emergent gameplay' | Randomly flying into spikes. |
| Time-Looping | 'Deep narrative layers' | Doing the same jump 50 times. |
| Passive Abilities | 'Strategic pacifism' | Walking simulator with extra steps. |
๐ Gamer Verdict
"A bunch of high-concept gimmicks trying to fill a void that only a bug with a needle can truly fix."
✅ The Good
- Occasionally beautiful art styles
- They aren't technically another carbon copy of Castlevania
❌ The Bad
- Experimental often equals frustrated controls
- Overpriced for 'Early Access' jank
๐ Global Quick Take
Tags: #Metroidvania #Silksong #IndieGames #GamingCritique #DontPreorder
Stay tuned for more gaming updates! Subscribe to our feed.
Source: Read Original Article
Comments
Post a Comment